Govt Tax Incentive Scheme Comparison Matrix

 VCLPESVCLPAngel Investment Tax Incentive SchemeVC-As-A-Service
Fund sizeNo upper limit$200m VC Act s9-3(1)(d)(ii)N/A$200m
Investor limitationsNilSophisticated investors if total ESIC investment over $50,000 p.a.Sophisticated investors pre-AFSL
All investors with AFSL
Min committed capital$10m commitment to go unconditional registrationN/A$10m commitment to go unconditional registration
Vehicle LifespanMin 5 yrs – max 15 years – VC Act 9-1(1)(c)Min 5 yrs – max 15 years – VC Act 9-3(1)(c)N/AMin 5 yrs – max 15 years
Min & max investment hold period12 months – 15 years12 months – 10 years 12 months – 15 years
Investor LimitsNo limit30% of committed capital – VC Act 9-3(1)(e)Non-sophisticated investors $50,000 p.a.30% of committed capital – VC Act 9-3(1)(e)
Investment Limit (per investee)30% of committed capital – ITAA 118-425(1)(d)20% of committed capital – ITAA 118-428(1)(c)N/A20% of committed capital – ITAA 118-428(1)(c)
Investment PlanNot requiredRequired – VC Act 9-3(1)(g)Not requiredRequired
Max Investee Entry value$250m – ITAA 118-440$50m – ITAA 118-440(9)No max prescribed but esic test sets a very low valuation$50m – ITAA 118-440(9)
Investment DivestmentNot requiredNil – VC Act 9-3(6) but tax benefits cease at $250 valueNilNil – VC Act 9-3(6) but tax benefits cease at $250 value
Investor Directed/AlignmentNoNo YesYes
Pooled Investment RiskFullFullNoMinimised
Investment Entity TypeVenture (high risk)Venture (high risk)Venture (high risk)Enterprise (low risk) to venture (high risk)
Investee listed at time of investmentNoNo No
Invest in listed sharesOnly if pre-listing shares are held.NoOnly if pre-listing shares are held.
New or existing sharesNew (+ existing with new holdings)NewNew (+ existing with new holdings)
Eligible investmentsITAA s. 118-425
· At risk (1)(a)

· Shares (1)(b)

· Investee Australian resident (2)

· Predominant activity (3)

· Registered auditor (5)

· Listed restrictions (7)

· Ineligible activities (13)

a) property development or land ownership;

b) finance;

i. banking;

ii. providing capital;

iii. leasing;

iv. factoring;

v. securitisation;

c) insurance;

d) construction;

e) making investments
ITAA s. 118-425
· At risk (1)(a)

· Shares (1)(b)

· Investee Australian resident (2)

· Predominant activity (3)

· Registered auditor (5)

· Listed restrictions (7)

· Ineligible activities (13)

a) property development or land ownership;

b) finance;

i. banking;

ii. providing capital;

iii. leasing;

iv. factoring;

v. securitisation;

c) insurance;

d) construction;

e) making investments
Early stage innovation companies (esic)
1. Early stage test

a. <$1m expenses in prior year

b. <=$200,000 income prior year

c. non-exchange

2. 100 point test

a. 50% of income to R&D expenses

b. Commercialisation grant

c. accelerator program

d. patents

e. university co-development.
ITAA s. 118-425
· At risk (1)(a)

· Shares (1)(b)

· Investee Australian resident (2)

· Predominant activity (3)

· Registered auditor (5)

· Listed restrictions (7)

· Ineligible activities (13)

a) property development or land ownership;

b) finance;

i. banking;

ii. providing capital;

iii. leasing;

iv. factoring;

v. securitisation;

c) insurance;

d) construction;

· making investments
Tax Handling
IncomeExemptPayableExempt
Capital GainExemptExemptExempt
Tax Offset10% of invested capital non-refundable carry forward ITAA97 s 61-765(1)20% of invested capital non-refundable carry forward but capped at $200,000 p.a.10% of invested capital non-refundable carry forward ITAA97 s 61-765(1)